Random Thoughts – Randocity!

GTA6: Rockstar made a HUGE mistake

Posted in botch, video game, video game design, video gaming by commorancy on November 20, 2026

GTA6 ImageGTA6 has been released for about a day and the PLAYER reviews so far are not all roses and daffodils. Note that as of the time of this article having been written on November 19, 2026, Metacritic is not allowing players to review the game on the Metacritic site. Metacritic will allow player reviews beginning on November 20th. For now, only the paid reviews by publications are being listed and boy have those reviews obviously gotten it so wrong. I expect these upcoming player reviews to be brutal for Rockstar.

Update: The Metacritic reviews are now rolling in. Read the first comment below for more details on how GTA6 is faring in user review ratings. Don’t expect more than about a 5 from most who’ve legitimately played the game. Let’s gamexplore.

Frame Rate Issues

Let’s also lead with the biggest problem that Rockstar faces. A problem, I might add, that Rockstar could have avoided entirely by developing the game correctly. Unfortunately, this issue is one issue that will lead to so many player-penned bad reviews that are yet forthcoming. What is this issue?

Developers must develop their games to perform properly and sanely on all consoles equally. That means, developing and testing the game on the lowest performing game console that is still being sold at the time of development. Why does this matter? It matters because developing on the lowest performing and smallest console ensures the game will operate correctly on all consoles, including the fastest and largest consoles. There is lots more that could be said here, but let’s move onto Rockstar’s issue.

Rockstar, unfortunately, chose to target development of GTA6 to operate properly on the fastest, largest console being produced… in the case of the PlayStation, that’s the PS5 Pro. While the game will run on the slowest and smallest PS5’s being sold today, it DOES NOT perform well… as many players have since discovered.

The game’s targeted frame rate is 30 frames per second. While 30fps is not really an expected frame rate these days for high quality AAA games, it is serviceable as long as that 30fps is rock stable. On the PS5 Pro, this might be the case. On lesser consoles, the frame rates can dip into the low 20s and even into the teens. These incredibly slow frame rates makes for a game that, at times, can be unplayable.

Development on Consoles / Statistics

The huge mistake that Rockstar made was not making development and testing on ALL console types a major priority as part of the last 13 years of GTA6 development. How can you get this far into developing a game like GTA6 and not realize that the game must play on ALL consoles equally?

This console development strategy has been commonplace knowledge for years. How can console developers not understand and, more importantly make targeting the lowest, slowest consoles a strategic milestone for the release of any video game? Let’s understand why this is important.

It has been estimated (as of late in 2025) that the PS5 Pro, at most, makes up about 13% of the total sales of the PS5s that have been sold in total. That means that 87% of the PS5’s out there are NOT PS5 Pro models. That also means that 87% of the overall PlayStation market is going to see poor performance, poor frame rates and experience problems from GTA6. Let’s put some hard numbers on that.

In total, around 100 million PS5s have sold since release. That means around 87 million gamers will experience performance problems playing GTA6, with around 13 million potentially not experiencing many problems. That assumes that all 100 million buy GTA6, which we know won’t happen. In fact, we know that only 24 million preorders have been sold for GTA6 so far. Those preorders include all platforms including the Xbox and PlayStation, and those numbers are not likely equally split down the middle between these two.

Of all of those copies that have been purchased by PlayStation owners and of those who own a PS5 Pro, the numbers are likely inordinately low for a preorder to have been sold to a PS5 Pro owner. Meaning, the vast majority of the copies sold to someone who owns a PS5, that game is most likely to land on a console that is not a Pro model. Meaning, the vast majority of PlayStation players are likely to experience frame rate problems while playing. This is not setting a great tone for the launch of a brand new game from an AAA developer.

The Sims

Here’s where we get into the content part of this game. The two protagonists in this game are Jason and Lucia. These two are a boyfriend / girlfriend pair. The player gets to play as these characters, but the story revolves around the relationship between these two. And, boy does it ever… The Sims much?

There is so much of a domestic aspect to this forced video game relationship, it hits way too close to home for comfort. We play video games to get away from the mundane dreary aspects of going to IKEA, buying a furniture kit and spending time building it on the living room floor. Why do we want to do this in a video game? Why do we want to fix a kitchen sink? Why do we want to fight with a girlfriend over cheating? Why do we want to deal with having babies with girlfriends?

Who at Rockstar really thought that this part of a Grand Theft Auto game was a good idea? The game should be about, as the game is titled, Grand Theft Auto. We’re there to mess around with the cars and all that goes with that. The game is not and should not be about building a home, love and relationships. It’s about heading out into the very large, brilliantly designed game world map and making mischief. We play for the mischief, not fighting with cheating girlfriends.

This game has become too much like The Sims, and not enough like Grand Theft Auto.

Open World Roaming

Know that GTA6 is a single player game. It does not support multiplayer. It does not support co-op. It does not support any player other than you playing by yourself. You will be roaming this world, after getting past all of the weird and unnecessary Sims parts, by yourself.

You will be playing either as Jason or Lucia depending. The game world map is big, open and has lots to explore. However, the game has also added a lot of new details that can help or harm your player depending on lots of RNG aspects. Like, forcing open the trunk of a car could reveal a very large snake. Showing up at a crashed plane site could reveal a gang looking to loot the plane just like you. You could steal a car only to find out that it has problems that prevents it from running. You could end up in a gang fight that could land cops on your doorstep because they heard the shots. Lots of these details are intended to get in your way.

All of this “added realism” only serves to turn GTA into The Sims more than being Grand Theft Auto. There is a point at which there is too much detail added.

Bugs

Many players have already run into various bugs, like falling through the map or objects clipping into walls or the physics engine running amok. All of these bugs may lead to poor performance or even potentially crashing. While the GTA5 devs were always cautious to release a mostly decent product, it seems that GTA6 was really released unfinished.

If you buy into GTA6 now, know that you’re playing beta tester for Rockstar.

Game Reviews

With all of the above said, the player reviews, especially those who run into all of the above, are not likely to be kind to Rockstar. These are the reviews that will be mostly honest. That assumes Metacritic doesn’t do something to silence many of the reviews that are coming.

If you’re considering the purchase of GTA6, know that it’s still a beta product that was not properly designed or tested against far too many consoles. Be cautious about dumping $80 into what seems to be an unfinished product. I’d suggest waiting for a few patch updates before considering the purchase of GTA6.

Note, I’m not going to give the game a rating here (other than what’s already been discussed) because the game is long and has many missions before completion. It’s difficult to rate the overall quality from start to finish. What I can say is that the release was premature, even after the many delays. GTA6 still needed at least another year’s worth of development time. Because it’s out now unfinished, we have to take it for what it is.

Follow, Like and Comment

If you enjoy content like this on Randocity, please follow and like. If you have an experience you’d like to share about playing GTA6, the comments are open.

↩︎

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. commorancy's avatar commorancy said, on November 20, 2026 at 4:01 pm

    To kick off the comments, here’s an update. The player Metacritic reviews have begun rolling in and, at least as of this moment, the general concensus is Generally unfavorable, citing all of the problems described above in the article and more. Yes, the in game content problems includes the poor protagonists, the inane forced relationship between Jason and Lucia, the domestic chores and the unlikability of Lucia, but also of Jason at times too. The technical problems include the frame rate issues.

    To dig a little deeper:

    The positive aspect of many reviews include the open world, the world detail, the beauty of the world and the map.

    The negative aspect of many reviews include the poor frame rate, many bugs, glitches, poor explosions and even mission soft locks. The negatives also include the boring and unnecessary relationship simulator that the game has become. Some have also commented that too many of the vehicles cannot be stolen, which sort of negates the fact that this is Grand Theft Auto.

    The average review score of those who write legitimate Metacritic reviews about the actual gameplay itself is about a 5.

    Yes, there are a number of what appear to be review bombs including both 0s and 10s. There are many one sentence reviews that rag on people “review bombing,” but never discuss the actual game itself. There are just as many 10 score reviews ragging on the 0 reviews, but never discussing the actual game. Lots of unnecessary review bombing from both sides.

    A 5 is a decent score for a game like GTA and is actually a reasonable score considering all of the technical compromises the Rockstar development team has foisted upon the gamers. For a $80-100 price tag, depending on when you bought and what version, it’s a high price tag for such a low performing game.

    Personally, I haven’t yet come to a score for the game myself. When I am able to rate the game properly, I will score the game. It’s too early for me to adequately score this game fully. However, I do agree that considering all of the above, the game is no better than a 5. That number could go up once Rockstar rolls a bunch of patch updates, but until that happens, a 5 is where it sits for now.

    Like


Comments are encouraged under these rules: 1. No personal attacks allowed. 2. Comments with personal attacks will not be posted. 3. Please keep your words civil. Thank you for contributing!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.